Editor’s Highlights | Opinion and Analysis
8th Jun 2012

My Three Favourite…Young Adult Heroines

When I was at school, young adult fiction didn’t really exist – there were children’s books and then at twelve or so you’d move onto grown-up novels.

Teen heroines were hard to find.  I gobbled up books about the super-spy Nancy Drew, first conceived in the 1920s, who novelist Bobbie Ann Mason calls: ‘as cool as a Mata Hari and as sweet as Betty Crocker’ – an expert horse-rider, gourmet cook, bridge player, oarswoman, French-speaker and great shot who, in the later books, went on adventures to far-flung spots like Nairobi and Costa Rica.

Then there was tomboy Jo March in Little Women (written in 1868!) and, erm….  I only remember a couple of contemporary teen-heroines, in books by trailblazers such as Judy Blume or Paula Danziger, whose character Cassie in The Pistachio Prescription feels like the first ‘teenage bomb in captivity’, and battles with asthma and an addiction to nuts to run in the school election.

Now, thanks in part to the Twilight franchise and the success of Bella Swan, YA heroines are everywhere.  My own, the cynical psychic Delilah Dark, is a kind of young Dorothy Parker, fighting an evil corporation with a crystal ball and a sharp tongue.  And every week seems to bring some new kickass girl destined to fight dragons, witch-hunters or evil dystopian regimes.  These are my three current favourites:

Katniss Everdeen from The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

Obvious, but come on!  Rebel, hunter, trader, archer – she can skin a lynx, live off pine-bark, identify wild berries and sleep up a tree.  Katniss outwits the Gamemakers, refusing to simply accept their system, and becomes a revolutionary in the process – she’s a perfect heroine for 2012, with young women around the globe joining movements like Occupy to question the future they are being offered.

Katniss can kill, but she’s also kind: she looks after her family and the little tribute Rue, and gets to save the guy.  As critic Manohla Dargis argues in The New York Times she: ‘isn’t locked into gender. She has assumed her dead father’s responsibility as the family provider and is also a mother surrogate for her sister, Prim. But Katniss doesn’t shift between masculinity and femininity; she inhabits both.’  Which makes her very cool indeed.

Sovay from Sovay by Celia Rees

There’s nothing better than sinking into one of Rees’ sumptuous historical novels.  This is the most fun of all – Savoy is an 18th century girl who rides out as a highwayman: testing the bravery of her suitors, giving the jewels to the poor and becoming a legend.  I love the fact she always wears a plume of gorse for luck, and her struggles with politics and destiny in a time of great upheaval.

Rees said she was inspired by the real tales of brave women in that period, including Mary Wollstonecraft, who wrote the radical feminist text A Vindication of the Rights of Women and was described as a ‘hyena in petticoats.’ As a poet, I also love the fact the book was inspired by an old ballad that begins:

            Sovay, Sovay all on a day
            She dressed herself in man’s array
            With a brace of pistols all by her side
            To meet her true love, to meet her true love, away she’d ride

Daisy from How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff

My favourite YA novel.  New Yorker Daisy is a flawed, lovely mess of a girl: she has an eating disorder and a defensive seen-it-all line in sarcasm, telling us: ‘I don’t get nearly enough credit in life for the things I manage not to say.’  But she’s brave enough to fall in love with her cousin Edmond, which in a time of approaching war might be the most dangerous thing you can do.

Daisy’s honesty makes her a heroine – as she tells us early on:  ‘It would be so much easier to tell this story if it were all about a chaste and perfect love between Two Children Against The World At An Extreme Time In History, but let’s face it, that would be a load of crap.’  By the end you’ll care about her so much you’ll be crying like a drain.

Who are your favourite young adult heroines? Do you prefer the modern girls, or are you a traditionalist at heart? Let us know!

Guest Post by Evie Glass, author of The Discoveries of Delilah Dark

(Image via Xanetia)

8 Responses to “My Three Favourite…Young Adult Heroines”

  1. Lauren says:

    I still can’t see Bella has a heroine. She’s more of a damsel in distress, but so is Edward. She’s too miserable all of the time, even when they’re actually together, that I just want to slap her face and tell her to get on with her life. I’d send her back to her mum’s house if I were her dad…

  2. Sarah says:

    Alanna from The Song of The Lionness series by Tamora Pierce wins hands down for me http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Song_of_the_Lioness I re-read all the books recently and what struck me most was how open and sensible they were talking about sex. Once she reaches her late teens and early twenties Alanna has lovers and at one point has to make a decision about whether she will marry her childhood sweetheart and settle down or go on adventuring.

  3. Amanda says:

    Katniss is a great choice, but it’s ‘Everdeen’ not ‘Evergreen’ right?

  4. [...] just read My Three Favourite… Young Adult Heroines on For Book’s Sake and it got me thinking about who I would pick. I’ve read The Hunger [...]

  5. Jess says:

    Growing up, mine were Nhamo from A Girl Named Disaster by Nancy Farmer, Cassie from Roll of Thunder Hear my Cry by Mildred Taylor, Helly from Goggle Eyes (in fact all of Anne Fine’s characters were pretty relatable) and of course Anastasia Krupnik!

  6. Alisande Fitzsimons says:

    I love this list. I was totally obsessed with Zazie from ‘Zazie dans Le Metro’ as a kid and Flora Poste from ‘Cold Comfort Farm’. They’re not traditional YA Books but they should be. Kickass teenage heroines.

  7. Sue Barsby says:

    Mattie from Jennifer Donnelly’s A Gathering Light is a great heroine. The novel always deserved a wider audience than just YA.
    I always liked the old fashioned ones when I was a kid, Jo March and Anne Shirley plus Judy Abbot from Daddy Long Legs.

Leave a Reply