Opinion and Analysis
14th Feb 2011
My Three Favourite…90s Chick-Lit Heroes

The 90s was a great decade for fiction; Jane Smiley won the Pulitzer Prize for A Thousand Acres, Harry Potter was invented, and we all fell hopelessly in love with Mark Darcy.
This was definitely the decade of Chick Lit; novels aimed at women, often reading for pleasure for the first time. Unlike the 80s bonk-busters by the likes of Jilly Cooper, Barbara Taylor Bradford and Danielle Steel, 90s chick-lit was real, identifiable women and men with real, identifiable problems.
As a genre, 90s chick-lit may get pissed on fairly regularly by the more snobbish readers out there. However, for many women in their twenties and thirties, these were the first books that they read for pleasure, and that should be celebrated.
So here, for Valentine’s Day, are my three favourite 90s chick-lit heroes. I’ve had crushes on them since my teens, and am not ashamed to admit it.
Josh in A Sense of Belonging by Erica James
Like most of my forays into chick-lit, I first read this book as a teenager, picking it mostly because the protagonist is a writer in her 30s called Jessica. She, along with a load of other characters, buys a house from a new barn conversion somewhere Southern and Posh in the Country, in order to be nearer her old mum.
One of her neighbours in the absolutely gorgeous Josh, who has recently found out that he has steadily worsening MS. Josh, as an active man in his 30s, takes the news of his illness very badly, pushing away all thoughts of love and friendship. At first he is incredibly rude to Jessica, but in the end, of course, everything works out as it should.
What I love about Josh is his obstinacy, and how heartbreaking it is for him to no longer be able to lead his life the same way. His desperate attempts to hide his illness from Jessica whilst trying to seduce her (including inventing excuses for not being able to speak or use cutlery) are so sad, but also so touching. They also share some wonderful love scenes together, important in romantic fiction.
Whilst the rest of the book meanders along, Jessica and Josh remain in my affections years afterwards. If you want classic late 90s chick-lit of the slightly mumsy variety, you can’t do better than Erica James.
Joe in Last Chance Saloon by Marian Keyes
I’ve already waxed lyrical on Leeds Book Club about my love for Marian Keyes. This book is another piece of classic 90s chick-lit, and was the first of hers that I read when I was about thirteen.
Joe is the new advertising creative working at the office where Katherine, our heroine, works as an accountant. Katherine is known as the Ice Queen around the office for her apparent lack of interest in men, and all that goes with them.
Of course, we know this is because of her massive insecurities and obsession with order, but when Joe falls head over heels for her, it takes a last request from a dying friend for Katherine to even accept that she is attracted to him.
Joe is a bit of a smart alec, and he doesn’t stand up to the casual office sexism in the way a true hero would. He does, however, take her on The Best First Date In Literature and is half of the slowest, sexiest sex scene in chick-lit. He also sounds like a proper ride.
Marian Keyes might be scorned by “readers” but I love her. So all you haters can, frankly, do one.
Ralph in Ralph’s Party by Lisa Jewell
Saving the best till last. I am unashamedly in love with Ralph. He is, come on, perfect. A tortured artist, he lives in squalor with his rich city-boy housemate Smith (the boom period hero is not complete without a rich city-boy housemate).
When Smith decides that they can’t just spend the entire time getting caned and watching telly Jem moves in, who both men instantly fall in love with.
I hate Jem. Hate her. She is exactly the sort of girl who every single man I’ve ever loved has fancied more than me. Small, pretty, huge knockers, nice hair, likes curry, GSOH.
Ralph is a slob. A gorgeous, skinny, messy, stoner slob. Together him and Jem have some of the best nights “as friends” that I’ve ever read. When she finally figures out that, duh, she loves him back, she gives this long list of reasons why.
I’ll admit it; I base almost my entire credentials of what to look for in a partner on a paragraph on page 252 of this book. I have been known to go through the list after dates, ticking them off. Don’t tell anyone, will you?
The ultimate of my guilty pleasures, I could read this book over and over. Again, incredibly silly in parts but so full of 90s ridiculousness I have to recommend it.
Which 90s chick-lit heroes did you have crushes on?
Jess Haigh



















Well BJD has to be up there. It really annoyed me in the second film that Mark Darcy didn’t seem to really ‘do’ anything to deserve to be with Bridget, so I stick to the books, where he is as dashing as dashing needs to be!
I didn’t read Fried Green Tomatoes until the 90′s (published in 87 I think), but I fell in love with Idgie sooo much! She was the best character, and a proper knight in shining armour to Ruth, her lady love.
Similarly the Rebecca Wells Ya Ya books (Little Altars Everywhere, Divine Secrets of the Ya Ya Sisterhood and Ya Ya’s in Bloom)don’t really feature romantic characters, but men who fit in alongside their wives/girlfriends/lovers friends and family, happy to be part of the unit, rather than demanding leading man status. So does it for me!
Read a lot of Mary Higgins Clark as a teenager, and loved how her books celebrated female protagonists, chosing equals as partners. Again, the men might not be centre stage, but they are written well enough to not be consigned to the whingy/moany/whiney mode that many secondary female characters are resigned to.
Yet for all that, I’m still doomed.
Sit me down with Gone with the Wind and within half an hour I’m muttering to myself in a southern style accent, longing for my very own Rhett Butler to storm in, toss me against the wall and kiss me.
I have a long way to go me…
Thanks for the comment, some interesting suggestions there! As for me, I’m just relieved that I’m not alone in still hopelessly lusting after Ralph from Ralph’s Party so many years later…..
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Avid Reader and Annette Barlow, For Books' Sake. For Books' Sake said: Another Valentine's Day treat for you: @BookElfLeeds' 3 favourite 90s chick-lit heroes! http://bit.ly/eFxxTJ [...]